| | | | Target: 10% increase in management effectiveness of the MPA (using METT)
- equivalent target under E-KKP3K to be identified, e.g. achieve 100% under the yellow or green rating |
| Scoping (Including Areal Extent of MPAs/MPA Networks) | | | X | The Coastal and Small Islands Conservation Area Within Bontang City Marine Area are as Follows:
1) Mangrove and Coral Conservation Area of Kedindingan and Surrounding Waters as much as 687.38 ha;
2) Park Area of Small Islands of Beras Basah Island and Surrounding Waters as much as 1,035.07 ha;
3) Coral Reef Conservation Area in Karang Segajah and Surrounding Waters as much as 366.43 ha.
4) Conservation Area of Melahing, and Surrounding Waters as much as 2,195.40
ha; and
5) Conservation Area of Tihik-Tihik as much as 841.10 ha.
Marine conservation area is managed by local government of Bontang City by applying principles of marine conservation management within the mangrove, seagrass, and coral reef conservation
area, the coral reef based tourism with snorkeling and diving activities on edindingan, beras basah and karang segajah, the beach based tourism on beras basah and karang segajah, and above water settlement tourism on Melahing, Selangan and Tihik-tihik. |
| Ecological, Social and Economic Characteristics, Significance and Conditions of MPA/MPA Network at Project Start-Up | | | X | Coastal and Small Islands Database Report of Bontang (2008 & 2015) Kedindingan
- Fish Diversity : 1.9
- Fish Abundance : 2,950
- Mangrove Density : 10.5
- Coral Covering : 62.5 %
- Coral Density : 8
- Physical Condition : Good
- Utilization : Medium
- Economic Value : High
Beras Basah
- Fish Diversity : 2.1
- Fish Abundance : 5,780
- Coral Covering : 74.1 %
- Coral Density : 8
- Physical Condition : Medium
- Utilization : High
- Economic Value : High
Karang Segajah
- Fish Diversity : 1.7
- Fish Abundance : 3,867
- Coral Covering : 48.3 %
- Coral Density : 8
- Physical Condition : High
- Utilization : High
- Economic Value : High
Melahing
- Fish Diversity : 1.4
- Fish Abundance : 550
- Coral Value Index : 1.9
- Coral Covering : 42.6 %
- Coral Density : 8
- Seagrass Density : 130
- Seagrass Diversity : 4
- Physical Condition : Medium
- Utilization : High
- Economic Value : Medium
Tihik-Tihik
- Fish Diversity : 1.9
- Fish Abundance : 3,950
- Coral Value Index : 1.9
- Coral Covering : 53 %
- Coral Density : 7
- Physical Condition : Medium
- Utilization : High
- Economic Value : Medium |
| MPA Governance Situation at Project Start-Up | | | X | 1. Ongoing Institutional Establishment of MPA Management System (Draft Management System Prepared in 2013, But needs further discussion with provincial government considering the change of authority to provincial level in 2014)
2. Ongoing preparation of Coastal and Marine Conservation Management Plan (Draft MPA Management Plan Prepared in 2013, but
needs further discussion with provincial government considering the change of
authority to provincial level in 2014) |
| METT Rating of Management Effectiveness of MPA at Project Start-Up | | | X | 1) Based on the decision of the Director General of Marine, Coastal and Small Islands, Ministry of Marine Affairs and Fisheries No. KEP.44/KP3K/2012, evaluation of the effectiveness of management of marine conservation areas in coasts and small islands in Indonesia will use EKKP3K
(Evaluasi Efektivitas Pengelolaan Kawasan Konservasi Perairan, Pesisir Dan Pulau-Pulau Kecil)
Based on the E-KKP3K System (Annex 3), the MPA in Bontang City Has Passed Level 1 (MPA Initiated).
2) The assessment of the progress of achieving management effectiveness goals for MPA in Bontang, Indonesia used the METT Score Card showed that from the 6 elements of evaluation there were only 5 elements that can be used such as Context, Planning, Inputs, Process, and Outcomes, which garnered a Total Score of 25.5%. The Planning Element has the highest score of 57.1 % of the adjusted maximum score, which focuses on Management Plan and Objectives. At the second rank of 46.2 % is Context Element focusing on the integration of The MPA in the Coastal Management Plan, Legal Status, Law Enforcement, and Resources Inventory. The significant progress achievement on the planning element is the MPA Management Plan because it has been prepared in 2013 involving stakeholders’ consultations with fisher groups, coastal communities, private sector, national and local agencies, etc. The period of the MPA Management Plan is 20 Years but is not being implemented yet because of changes of national law which moved authority to the provincial level. This is the reason why the MPA Management Unit has not been established yet and implementation of management plan is on hold pending clarification with the province on implementation mechanism and budget. Meanwhile, the significant progress achievement on the context element is the Integration of the MPA in Coastal Management Plan because the MPA is part of the long-term and medium-term Development Plan, and Management Plan for Coastal Dan Small Island. |
| | X | | Based on the project document for GEF-UNDP Regional Project on Scaling-Up the Implementation of the SDS-SEA, the expected target on the end of project in 2019 is to have 10% improvement in METT rating compare to baseline survey |
| New or Improved MPA Management Plan | X | | | Draft MPA Management Plan Prepared in 2013, but needs to be reviewed in consultation with provincial government.
Updating of the MPA Management Plan will take into consideration the current legal and administrative and legal arrangements, the results of the E-KKP3K and METT assessments and priority areas for improvement to be discussed with stakeholders, as well as the results of the risk/vulnerability assessment. |
| Improvements Recorded at Priority MPA Sites Using METT Indicators | | | | To be assessed at the end of the project |
